Discussion Question – Hero’s Journey


It surprises me greatly that nobody has posted about The Hobbit or Lord of the Rings as their examples of the Hero’s Journey. To me, no book or movie holds up as a better example, except maybe Harry Potter.

Let’s start with our Tolkien Heroes. In The Hobbit, this of course is Bilbo Baggins (And believe me, I am judging you harshly if you don’t already know this … (: ) and it LOTR, it is his nephew Frodo. They are hobbits, from the Shire, and seen by the rest of the creatures and man in Middle Earth as nonthreatening, if they even know what a hobbit is. In both of their journeys, however, they prove to be of great use or valiant character.

In The Hobbit, Bilbo is offered his call to adventure when the legendary wizard Gandalf shows up and asks him if he’d like to go on a quest. Bilbo quickly declines his offer and in a show of the endless kindness of hobbits, politely invites him over for tea. The call to adventure comes again the next day with a knock at his door – “Dwalin, at your service,” – followed by twelve more dwarves and Gandalf again, this time there to explain their quest as Bilbo scrambles to throw an unexpected dinner party. ┬áThe next morning Bilbo wakes up to realize his party is gone, and runs out the door shouting to a passerby, “I’m going on an adventure.” Here we’ve gone through the call, the refusal, and even dabbled in supernatural aid.

In LOTR I find the finest example of crossing the threshold. Frodo, accompanied by Sam Gamgee, is attempting to meet Gandalf in Bree just outside of the Shire. In the movie, Sam stops in the middle of the wheat field, and tells Frodo that this is it; the farthest point he’s ever been. This moment marks the point that Sam and Frodo leave the comforts of home and are truly into the unknown.

I could write for hours making in depth comparisons of the novels/movies to The Hero’s Journey for Tolkien’s work but I’ll make things short and stick to just one novel, The Hobbit. Bilbo is forced to “prove” himself to his company, which is manages to partially do (all except for Thorin) after finding the ring in the cave with Gollum – his “belly of the whale” – and sneaking up on the party. His road of trials includes fighting goblins, having a riddle battle with Gollum to survive, the trolls, the spiders, and having the entire dwarven party be captured by the elves in Mirkwood – which Bilbo manages to save them from. There’s no temptress in the form of a woman in The Hobbit – but there is the ring, which proves in the later LOTR books to be exactly a temptress.



2. Most cinematic features today I believe wouldn’t serve the purpose defined by the four functions if simply because every movie today is a retelling of older stories – hence the new Hobbit movies coming out, the Marvel movies, and remaking a not yet outdated spiderman movie. These are stories we’re all comfortable with, and they’re remade to be simple and shallow. It’s hard to find a movie these days that is a true coming of age story that encourages the reader. There are exceptions to every rule, however, and some movies (even adaptions like The Book Thief,) fulfill the deeper need that human beings have traditionally filled with stories.

3 thoughts on “Discussion Question – Hero’s Journey

  1. awatso21 Post author

    Oh, lord, ignore my horrible conclusion sentence. I’m on like twelve different cold medications and can’t quite think straight. . .

  2. nelsoncrockett

    Very good point with the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings being excellent examples of the heroes journey. I have a question though as to whether todays movies are simple and shallow or if the key story that they tell has all the depth that it needs but the format that it is told in fails to transmit that message? Also considering that many of these older origin stories are so old and have been retold time after time can an alteration to the original material make a better story?

  3. Jared

    I thought it was funny that you mentioned that no one had posted about LOTR. I did not take the time to sift through what was posted before I posted this morning about LOTR as my “Hero” story. I did not point out the same crossing the threshold point as you, but after reading your article, I was stunned that I had not thought of that! Overall good summarizing and relation to points in the story.

    I agree with you on the redundancies of movies today. How many times can they remake the same series? Also, I agree that most movies lack the content necessary to fulfill all of the functions or needs there of. Some do though and I highly suggest you watch “The Cloud Atlas,” if you have not.

Comments are closed.